Welcome!

Cloud Expo Authors: Roger Strukhoff, Dave Geada, Pat Romanski, Liz McMillan, Mark Skilton

Related Topics: Virtualization, Linux, Open Source, Cloud Expo

Virtualization: Article

Xen, KVM and the Linux Choice

Xen and KVM each have their own respective strengths

There has been a significant amount of derision heaped on Xen after its successful integration into the Linux kernel last month.

One wouldn't think such criticism is warranted, since the inclusion of Xen in the Linux kernel puts it on equal footing with KVM.

Yet, when Oracle's Wim Coekaerts announced the inclusion of Xen code for DomO and DomU support in Linux, many industry observers took the opportunity to lambaste Xen for being too-little-too-late.

True, KVM has been more successful in the briefer time it has existed. Xen has had plenty of opportunity to be the go-to virtualization platform for Linux. KVM, however, exploded in popularity and was fully integrated into the Linux kernel by the time Linux 2.6.20 was released. It's now the virtualization platform of choice for Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Canonical's Ubuntu Server, and SUSE Enterprise Server Linux (though SLES also supports Xen as well).

The fact that Xen is now in the Linux kernel is a cause for celebration. Customers who want to work with a virtualization solution now have a choice of not one but two solid virtualization tools for Linux. This proves once and for all that Linux is not only a viable cloud virtualization platform; it's in reality the most desirable platform for use in the cloud.

Xen and KVM each have their own respective strengths. Despite their differences - indeed, because of their differences - their mutual presence within the Linux kernel validates that cloud computing will truly be commoditized, no matter which approach to virtualization is desired by customers.

That's a big perspective, much bigger than the narrow view of Xen being "late."

To have real commoditization, the choice of the underlying platform must be driven by the application, not the platform features. No matter which virtualization toolset customers prefer (KVM or Xen), Linux has now become the crucible of both. Applications become the important deciding factor.

The presence of both in the Linux kernel should put VMware on notice that their market position with VMware ESX Server is becoming tenuous at best, since commoditization has finally been achieved.

The industry is certainly coming around to that conclusion. KVM, for instance, enjoys broad industry support by Red Hat and other members of the Open Virtualization Alliance (OVA). OVA's members, including the 65 new members of which Convirture is one, understand that having KVM in the Linux kernel means proprietary approaches like VMware's are no longer important.

The two virtualization systems can be used equally by independent cloud vendors to break the hold VMware and Citrix have on the cloud market. OVA and its expanded membership have all but declared open war on VMware in particular and sees itself as a chance to end VMware domination. With Xen's inclusion in the Linux kernel, industry alignment around Xen can be expected as well.

The choice demonstrates once and for all that Linux is the real and right platform for virtualization. And since virtualization is the first step toward cloud computing, Linux ultimately becomes the best choice for the cloud.

More Stories By Arsalan Farooq

Arsalan Farooq is CEO and Founder of Convirture. He brings over 15 years of systems management experience to his role as the CEO. Previously, he was the founding Director of the Application Service Level Management (ASLM) division at Oracle, where he was responsible for all aspects of market strategy and product development. Under his leadership, ASLM grew from a two person engineering team into a high-performance, multi-national organization spearheading Oracle's entry into the Applications Management space.

Prior to founding ASLM, Arsalan held various management roles at Oracle, where he helped deliver multiple generations of the Oracle Enterprise Manager product suite. he started his career as a multimedia software designer at Knowledge Adventure and as the founder of his own technology consultancy firm while still in college.

Arsalan holds degrees in Theoretical Physics and Computer Science from Reed College and Caltech, respectively.

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Cloud Expo Breaking News
SYS-CON Events announced today that LSI Corporation, a leading provider of innovative silicon and software technologies for the storage and networking markets, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 9th International Cloud Expo, which will take place on November 7–10, 2011, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. LSI Corporation provides silicon and software technologies that seamlessly bring people, information, and digital content together. LSI offers a broad portfolio of capabilities and...
SYS-CON Events announced today that INetU, a leading managed hosting and cloud provider, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 9th International Cloud Expo, which will take place on November 7–10, 2011, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. INetU is a leading managed hosting provider serving customers worldwide. Dedicated to building long-term relationships with its clients, INetU supports many popular Web applications and provides highly reliable hosting for enterprise websites in the O...
Financial services tend to be the early adopters of most technology and have forward-thinking developers on staff. However, only 30% of financial services data centers have been virtualized. Meanwhile, those prolific developers are either already using public cloud resources or are trying to. What will be the business impact of avoiding the cloud conversation? In his general session at Cloud Expo New York, Abiquo CEO Pete Malcolm discussed whether financial services organizations are risking se...
Many enterprises are struggling to develop a cloud computing strategy. Cloud computing seems like it ought to be a game-changing technology, but so often when the initial proof of concept is finished, it appears to have simply rearranged the deckchairs within a titanic IT department. The problem is we have been trained through decades of IT implementation to focus on certain metrics. Unfortunately, those are the wrong ones. Consequently, when it comes to cloud computing, most of us are playing "...
The advantages of using the cloud are apparent, but the approaches to the cloud are still in a heated industry debate. Renting cloud space from a vendor, private clouds, open clouds – just what is the best choice and where is the industry heading? While renting cloud space from a vendor seems easy, it’s difficult to move off these clouds, and it’s especially problematic when you’d like to test another provider’s cloud. Private clouds tie you into a verticalized stack, limiting flexibility and ch...
As cloud application adoption becomes pervasive throughout the enterprise, concerns around cloud data privacy, residency, and security continue to grow. A number of enterprises are slowing, and even reversing, their cloud application adoption until they can address the concerns stemming from regulatory compliance requirements, industry standards, or internal policies surrounding sensitive data management. In his general session at Cloud Expo New York, Terry Woloszyn, Founder/CTO of PerspecSys ...
While the Cloud is a common future for a majority of IT shops, we believe there are two principle cloud development concepts to examine before you develop or proceed too far with your cloud strategies. Should you take an evolutionary path and transform your existing IT environment to a cloud of service computing… or do you jump to the “head of the cloud”, and revolutionize your approach with a comprehensive cloud solution… or both. In his general session at Cloud Expo New York, Andi Mann, vice...
There is one constant in data centers: application groups always need more. Until recently, apps have been at the mercy of IT operations to feed their need. In his keynote at Cloud Expo 2011 New York, Abiquo CEO Pete Malcolm discussed how, with the advent of public cloud offerings, apps can bypass ops entirely and get the resources they need with just a few clicks and a credit card. What does this mean for the future of IT ops?
With substantial growth in cloud services, over 2.5 billion connected users, more than 1000 exabytes of Internet traffic and 15 billion devices accessing cloud services by 2015, transforming datacenters to support this growth can be complex. To address the challenges facing IT and realize significant benefits of cloud computing, it’s essential that cloud solutions are open, interoperable and built on standards. In his general session at Cloud Expo New York, Jason Waxman, Intel Data Center Grou...
What has made this week different from any other week? This was the opening question posed by Jeremy Geelan, Cloud Expo Conference Chair, in this Wrap-Up Power Panel held at the 8th International Cloud Expo at the Javits Center in New York City, June 6-9, 2011. Panelists included John Keagy, Founder & Executive Chairman at GoGrid; Scott Morrison, CTO and Chief Architect at Layer 7 Technologies; Andrew Hillier, Co-Founder and CTO at CiRBA; Tim Negris, VP of Marketing at 1010data; Stephen Sicola, ...