Thorsten von Eicken's RightScale Blog

It looks like pretty soon all computing will be called cloud computing, just because the cloud is "in." Fortunately most computer savvy folks actually have a pretty good idea of what the term "cloud computing" means: outsourced, pay-as-you-go, on-demand, somewhere in the Internet, etc. What is still confusing to many is how the different offerings compare from Amazon Web Services to Google App Engine and Force.com. I recently heard a characterization of three different levels of clouds which really helps put the various offerings into perspective.

Here’s my rephrasing:

Applications in the cloud: this is what almost everyone has already used in the form of gmail, yahoo mail, wordpress.com (hosting this blog), the rest of google apps, the various search engines, wikipedia, encyclopedia britannica, etc. Some company hosts an application in the internet that many users sign-up for and use without any concern about where, how, by whom the compute cycles and storage bits are provided. The service being sold (or offered in ad-sponsored form) is a complete end-user application. To me all this is SaaS, Software as a Service, looking to join the ‘cloud’ craze.

Platforms in the cloud: this is the newest entry where an application platform is offered to developers in the cloud. Developers write their application to a more or less open specification and then upload their code into the cloud where the app is run magically somewhere, typically being able to scale up automagically as usage for the app grows. Examples are Mosso, Google App Engine, and Force.com. The service being sold is the machinery that funnels requests to an application and makes the application tick.

Infrastructure in the cloud: this is the most general offering that Amazon has pioneered and where RightScale offers its management platform. Developers and system administrators obtain general compute, storage, queueing, and other resources and run their applications with the fewest limitations. This is the most powerful type of cloud in that virtually any application and any configuration that is fit for the internet can be mapped to this type of service. Of course it also requires more work on the part of the buyer, which is where RightScale comes in to help with set-up and automation.

Looking at these different types of clouds it’s pretty clear that they are geared toward different purposes and that they all have a reason for being. The platforms in the cloud are a very interesting offering in that they promise to take some of the mundane pain away from dealing with the raw infrastructure. But it’s not at all clear to me that the vendors can live up to the promise of managing everything seamlessly and that the functional constraints won’t cause applications to have to move up to the infrastructure clouds as they mature and gain complexity. It would not be good if toy apps started on the platform clouds and then moved to the infrastructure clouds as they gain adoption. One possible outcome is a hybrid model where the canonical application core remains in the platform cloud and the odd pieces of functionality and/or the parts that need to scale the most drastically move off to infrastructure clouds.


[This appeared originally here and is republished by kind permission of the author, who retains copyright.]

• IBM & Google Go Cloud Chasing
• IBM's Got Its Head in the Clouds
• IBM Pushes Cloud to China, EU
• When Yahoo! Says Cloud, It Means a Freakin' Big Cloud
• Virtual Cloud Computing
• The Missing Piece in Cloud Computing
• Intalio Goes to the Cloud
• Cloud Computing - IBM Creates Cloud Box
• Amazon Offers Cloud Support
• Cloud Computing Casts Shadow on Walled Gardens
• Cloud Computing: Java and AJAX Over the Cloud
• HP Virtualization to Field Cloud Storage
• Cloud Formation
• Cloud Computing Expo - Cloud Spotting
• Virtualization - Google Puts a Price on Its Cloud
• HP Wants To Be a Cloud Builder
• What is Cloud Computing?
• Cloud Computing Expo: Introducing the Cloud Pyramid
• Amazon’s Elastic Block Store Opens Up S3 and The Cloud
• Virtualization & Cloud Computing: Perfect Together
• Cloud Computing: Who Can Help Me Get an Application onto EC2 and Storage onto S3?
• A Brief History of Cloud Computing: Is the Cloud There Yet?
• Joyent CEO to Present on "The Open Cloud" at SYS-CON's Cloud Computing Expo
• Is It Time Yet To Move Towards Cloud Computing Standards?
• [Flashback to 2008] Is Google the Elephant in the Cloud?
• Cloud Computing Keynote at SYS-CON's Cloud Computing Expo November 19-21 in Silicon Valley
• Exclusive Q&A with Cloud Computing CEO Michael Crandell
• Seasonal Gifts From Google App Engine
• Did Google's Eric Schmidt Coin "Cloud Computing"?
• Citrix CEO "The Industry Needs Time"